Baking 3Cs began as a family tradition. We are large--EHEM--big-boned people who love a good cookie, and so my mom always included my brother and I in the process as we followed the recipe off the back of the Nestle Tollhouse Chocolate Chip bag. As time passed, something alarming started to happen, and was nearly a catalyst for a complete identity crisis. My younger brother, who had (supposedly) no aptitude in the kitchen, suddenly started churning out the most delicious 3C cookies in the family. I took this pretty hard, as there was only room for one "Martha" in our little clan, and that Martha was ME! I was determined to craft a cookie that would upstage him, therefore returning balance to the universe.
During the ensuing years at College, Grad-School, and into my post-student What-the-crap-am-I-doing-with-my-life phase, I had many occasions to practice my 3C art. These cookies became a way to advertise my skills to cute boys. They were a way to tell dear friends, "I'm happy to have you over," "Thanks for letting me spend time with you," or "He was a total jerk anyway, so let's get chip-faced and watch a Meg Ryan movie." They also became currency of sorts. "I will bake you cookies if....." I have had various car repairs, home repairs, and other unpleasant tasks completed for me for the low low price of a plate of these cacao-speckled beauties.
Now, many of you may just be bearing with me, all the while thinking, "c'mon, a 3C is just a 3C, what makes yours so special?" Well, doubting Debbie, I'm sure glad you asked! These cookies are special for 2 main reasons. 1.) The perfect marriage of spices and auxiliary ingredients and 2.) the baking time. Never EVER over-bake these cookies. I will walk you through the baking shortly, but I will say that the main reason the cookies taste so good is the gooey texture that comes from them being just slightly under-baked. There is nothing more sad than an over-baked cookie. I remember the first time a good friend saw me completely fly off the handle, and become my own domestic version of Mr. Hyde. I over-baked my cookies and friends, it was NOT pretty.
Now ye have been warned, and it's time to get down to it. Are you ready to learn how to make the Best Chocolate Chip Cookie in the whole dag gum world? Most of the ingredients for 3Cs can be found in any moderate to well-stocked pantry, and if you don't have sugar, flour, spices and chocolate chips on hand...well then, perhaps you should take a good hard look at your pantry priorities.
Ingredients
3/4 c. white sugar
1 c. packed dark brown sugar
2 eggs
1 tsp. vanilla extract
1/4 tsp. maple flavoring
Spoonful o' peanut butter. (I like to use creamy, but chunky is fine. You can be generous with the PB....usually my spoonful overfloweth)
2 1/2c. flour
1 tsp. salt (sea salt preferred)
1 tsp. baking soda
1/8 tsp. cinnamon
dash o' ground ginger
1 c. oats
1/2 bag of chocolate chip cookies (I prefer to use semisweet, but go with what you know and love. You could get really crazy and do a mix of milk chocolate, dark, semisweet, morsels, chunks, or what have you. The sky is the limit.)
Some of these ingredients, such as the white to brown sugar ratio, peanut butter, the maple flavoring, cinnamon, ginger and sea salt may seem strange to you. There is a method to my madness. The brown sugar lends a chewiness and depth to the flavor, while the maple brings caramelly richness to the cookie. Cinnamon warms everything up, while the hint of ginger brightens all the flavors. Sea Salt really brings out the chocolate. Salt does not offend me and I like to taste it in my cookies.
Preheat your oven to 350 degrees F.
In a large bowl, cream together the butter and sugars. For those of you with fancy kitchens, have fun using your handheld mixer and/or kitchen aid. I prefer to hand mix everything with a giant wooden spoon. It reminds me of my college dorm-room days and makes me feel just that much more badass.
Add the eggs and extracts, mixing everything well. Mix in the peanut butter, and get ready to incorporate the dry ingredients.
In a separate bowl, mix together the flour, spices, salt, and baking soda. Add this slowly to the wet ingredients.
Once everything is well incorporated, add the oats, and mix well. Now stir in the chocolate chips, and you are ready to bake!
Using whatever method works for you, (I like using 2 spoons,) drop the cookies onto an UN-greased baking sheet. Try to keep them uniform in size to facillitate even baking.
Now pop them in the oven for 8-10 minutes, and HEY! Where are you going? Don't you EVEN think of leaving the kitchen at this point! Too often I have made the mistake of going about my daily life, blithely forgetting about the poor innocent cookies that may be over-baking, due to my negligence. The timer may still say that they have a few more minutes, but you need to keep an eye on them! Every oven cooks differently, and it would be a shame to ruin a good batch of cookies. You will know the cookies are done when they are just set. What does that mean? Well, when they are no longer shiny on top, and are just starting to turn a light golden (not brown) on the sides. If they fit this description, get them out of the oven, and let them finish baking for 2 minutes on the sheet. Then, you may remove them from the baking sheet and transfer the 3Cs to a wire rack or plate, or--let's be honest, your mouth. More cookies than I care to admit take a fatal detour right from the baking sheet to my mouth, and never get to experience life on the cooling rack.
And there you have it. I stand by this recipe, and I would encourage any of my friends out there who have tasted these droplets of heaven to post testimonials below. Happy Baking!

